HVAC services are essential in an area with as cold a winter and muggy a summer as New York. Without effective heating and air conditioning, New Yorkers are guaranteed to suffer at some point throughout the year. To help property owners find the best HVAC provider for them, we have researched over 30 HVAC providers that serve the Long Island area and ranked them based on the following criteria:
- Value Score: Our 1-5 score that summarizes a businesses value based on their pricing, service quality (based on relevant reviews from reputable sites), availability, and service library.
- Year Established: When companies have been around for a long time, it shows that they’ve made customers happy enough to keep coming back to them for service again and again.
- Heating Oil Delivery: Heating oil is one of the oldest heating methods in New York, and many residences still use it in our historic neighborhoods, so we give an edge to companies that offer heating oil delivery and tank service.
- 24/7 Emergency Service Availability: HVAC system failures don’t happen on your schedule, so we prioritize companies that offer 24/7 emergency service.
- Other Home Services Offered: Being able to get multiple home services from the same company means not having to roll the dice on several different companies to find some you can trust, so we give a bump to companies that offer more home services.
Below are our rankings of the best HVAC companies in Long Island after considering all of the factors above:
The Best HVAC Companies in Long Island, NY
| Rank | Company | Value Score | Established | Heating Oil? | 24/7 Emergency Service? | Other Home Services Offered |
| 1 | Victory Skaggs | 4.8 | 1933 | Yes | Yes | Water Heaters, Plumbing, Electrical, Pest Control |
| 2 | Petro Home Service | 4.6 | 1903 | Yes | Yes | Generators |
| 3 | Varsity Home Service | 4.5 | 1962 | No | Yes | Water Heaters, Water Filtration, Plumbing |
| 4 | GallettAir Inc. | 4.3 | 1983 | No | Yes | Water Heaters |
| 5 | Tragar Home Services | 4.2 | 1956 | Yes | Yes | Water Filtration |
| 6 | Long Island HVAC | 3.9 | Unknown | No | Yes | N/A |
| 7 | Meenan | 3.6 | 1934 | Yes | Yes | Heating Oil, Generators, Chimney service |
Victory Skaggs
Victory Skaggs is a family-owned HVAC company that has been in operation for almost a century. Their high Value Score is a result of competitive pricing, affordable service plans, high reviews, and unique X-factors like their own custom ductwork fabrication facility that allows them to tackle any HVAC job no matter how complex. Whether its central air, mini splits, or furnaces, Victory-Skaggs can get the work done on your schedule, and do it right the first time.
In addition to everything that makes them a premium HVAC company, they also provide more home services than any other firm on the list, including efficient Bioheat heating oil for homes that still use it. Each of these services is run through a local expert team that they acquired specifically so that each of them would be high-quality and not just an “accessory service” provided by an HVAC company.
- Value Score: 4.8
- Year Established: 1933
- Repair and Replacement Services?: Yes
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: Yes
- Other Home Services Offered: Water Heaters, Plumbing, Electrical, Pest Control
- Contact: Victory Skaggs website
Petro Home Services
Petro Home Services is an HVAC and heating oil provider that serves much of the Northeast, including Long Island. Their combination of fuel oil service and HVAC repair makes them a great choice for customers looking for year-round service, and those in older properties with heating oil systems. They offer full-service HVAC, heating oil services, and generator installation.
They also offer value-driven service plans, and they don’t rely on seasonal coupons that could make pricing inconsistent.
- Value Score: 4.6
- Year Established: 1903
- Heating Oil?: Yes
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: Yes
- Other Home Services Offered: Generators
- Contact: Petro Home Service
Varsity Home Service
Varsity Home Service is another HVAC company with an impressive list of home services to complement their core offerings. They have great reviews, and they offer water plumbing services, which are commonly needed for more extensive HVAC repairs. They have a long history of offering high-quality home service, which makes their lack of heating oil delivery/service a bit surprising. Outside of this, they are a great and versatile service provider.
They offer versatile maintenance plans to improve their value, but we don’t love how many temporary/seasonal coupons and offers they list on their site because these suggest some level of inconsistency in pricing depending on when you need service.
- Value Score: 4.5
- Year Established: 1962
- Heating Oil?: No
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: Yes
- Other Home Services Offered: Water heaters, Water Filtration, Plumbing
- Contact: Varsity Home Service website
GallettAir Inc.
GallettAir is one of the best-reviewed pure HVAC providers on the list. While they are among the youngest companies listed, they’ve still been around for over 40 years, and have already established a strong track record for good work. Their customers trust them, so we do too.
Technically, they aren’t purely HVAC, as they also offer water heaters, but we consider this a pure HVAC team since water heaters can fall under the “H” in HVAC.
As for pricing, they offer service contracts and we do not see many seasonal coupons on their site often, which means consistent pricing and no need for “deal hunting” with a broken AC or heater!
- Value Score: 4.3
- Year Established: 1983
- Heating Oil?: No
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: Yes
- Other Home Services Offered: Water Heaters
- Contact: GallettAir Inc. website
Tragar Home Services
Tragar Home Services is a full-service HVAC firm that also offers heating oil and water filtration. While they offer heating oil, they don’t offer the same variety of services or as strong of reviews as some companies listed above them that don’t. They also rely a bit too much on seasonal coupons and deals, which pulls their value score down a bit.
- Value Score: 4.5
- Year Established: 1956
- Heating Oil?: Yes
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: Yes
- Other Home Services Offered: Water Filtration
- Contact: Tragar Home Services website
Long Island HVAC
Another pure HVAC company, Long Island HVAC offers no other services but does have great reviews from customers throughout Long Island. They offer affordable pricing, rely on no seasonal or temporary pricing, and they also offer financing. While their Value Score would be higher if they offered other home services, and they don’t disclose their founding date on their website, they have about as high a score as a company can have considering those facts.
- Value Score: 3.9
- Year Established: Unknown
- Heating Oil?: No
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: Yes
- Other Home Services Offered: N/A
- Contact: Long Island HVAC website
Meenan
Meenan is a full-service HVAC provider, and they also serve heating oil customers with both delivery and repair services. Additionally, they can service chimneys and install generators. While their pricing and payment options offer value, their Value Score was dinged significantly by below-par review scores on several larger review sites. Concerns about the consistency of their quality and pricing kept them from being higher on the list, but they have been around a very long time and do have enough positive reviews to suggest that they offer good value overall.
- Value Score: 3.6
- Year Established: 1934
- Heating Oil?: Yes
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: Yes
- Other Home Services Offered: Generators, Chimney service
- Contact: Meenan website
