Heating oil is one of the most common heating methods in New York, and there are a lot of providers to choose from when deciding who you want to deliver your fuel. We have analyzed over 30 of the best heating oil companies in Long Island, done a deep dive into what they have to offer, and provided a ranking based on the following criteria:
- Value Score: A 1.0-5.0 score that incorporates the pricing of heating oil delivery and other services, their service variety, quality (based on relevant reviews), and the expertise of their team.
- Year Established: Older companies have stuck around as long as they have by doing great work at an affordable price and leaving customers happy.
- Replacement and Repair Services: Heating oil delivery is all a company needs to be called a heating oil provider, but we prioritize companies that can also replace oil tanks and repair heating equipment since it makes it a lot easier for their customers to have a single heating services provider.
- 24/7 Emergency Service Availability: Heating system failures don’t happen on your schedule, so we prioritize companies that offer 24/7 emergency service.
- Other Home Services Offered: It can be a nice bonus to know that the heating provider you trust can also help you with other services. As a result, we give a small edge to companies that offer other home services.
Below are our rankings of the best heating oil companies in Long Island after considering all of the factors above:
The Best Heating Oil Companies in Long Island, NY
| Rank | Company | Value Score | Established | Replacement and Repair Services? | 24/7 Emergency Service? | Other Home Services Offered |
| 1 | Skaggs-Walsh | 4.8 | 1933 | Yes | Yes | HVAC, Plumbing, Electrical, Pest Control |
| 2 | Petro Home Service | 4.6 | 1903 | Yes | Yes | Oil and Gas Heat, HVAC, Generators |
| 3 | Tragar Home Services | 4.5 | 1956 | Yes | Yes | HVAC, Water Filtration |
| 4 | Just Fuel | 4.4 | 1997 | No | No | N/A |
| 5 | Johns Fuel Oil Inc. | 4.1 | 1988 | Yes | Yes | HVAC |
| 6 | All Island Fuel | 3.9 | 1990 | Yes | No | N/A |
| 7 | Meenan | 3.6 | 1934 | Yes | Yes | HVAC, Generators, Chimney service |
Skaggs-Walsh
Skaggs-Walsh is a family-owned heating oil company that has been in operation for almost a century and has since expanded into multiple home services. Their high value score comes from their reasonable pricing, value-added service and tank protection plans, great reviews, and unique X-factors like their own 400,000 gallon fuel reserve that ensures they’ll never run out of fuel during the winter, and their massive fleet of trucks that ensures they don’t get overbooked. They can repair heating systems, replace oil tanks, and remove your existing tank. They also offer consistent pricing, meaning you don’t have to rely on seasonal coupons or promo periods to lock in affordable heating oil delivery.
In addition to everything that makes them a top-notch heating oil company, they also offer the widest variety of home services on the list. These services aren’t afterthoughts, either– each of them is run through a local expert team that they acquired specifically for their positive reputation and the expertise of their leadership.
- Value Score: 4.8
- Year Established: 1933
- Repair and Replacement Services?: Yes
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: Yes
- Other Home Services Offered: HVAC, Plumbing, Electrical, Pest Control
- Contact: Skaggs-Walsh website
Petro Home Services
Petro Home Services delivers fuel oil and provides home services to Long Island customers and many more across much of the Northwest. Their combination of fuel oil service and HVAC repair makes them a great choice for customers looking for year-round service. They offer full-service HVAC and generator installation alongside their fuel oil and equipment repair services.
They do offer flexible service plans, which makes them an even better value. They don’t rely on seasonal coupons or promotions to provide good value, so customers don’t have to worry about unexpected price increases.
- Value Score: 4.6
- Year Established: 1903
- Repair and Replacement Services?: Yes
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: Yes
- Other Home Services Offered: Oil and Gas Heat, HVAC, Generators
- Contact: Petro Home Service
Tragar Home Services
Tragar Home Services is a full-service heating oil and HVAC company that can also handle whole-home water filtration. While they offer similar value to Skaggs-Walsh in their pricing and service plan availability, they don’t offer all of the same guarantees like their own large fuel reserves. They also get a small ding due to some of their lower price points being reliant on seasonal deals and coupons, suggesting that customers can’t necessarily rely on consistent pricing year-round.
Tragar’s other services include HVAC and whole-home water filtration, so they do get a bump for being able to repair and install all kinds of heating and cooling equipment.
- Value Score: 4.5
- Year Established: 1956
- Repair and Replacement Services?: Yes
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: Yes
- Other Home Services Offered: HVAC, Water Filtration
- Contact: Tragar Home Services website
Just Fuel
Just Fuel’s name does a good job explaining their service offerings: They just deliver fuel. That being said, they have exceptional reviews and very competitive price points, so for customers who are focused on simply paying as little as possible and who don’t mind going to multiple providers to get repair and installation services, Just Fuel could be a good option.
- Value Score: 4.4
- Year Established: 1997
- Repair and Replacement Services?: No
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: No
- Other Home Services Offered: N/A
- Contact: Just Fuel website
John’s Fuel Oil, Inc.
John’s Fuel Oil, Inc. offers heating oil delivery and repair/replacement specifically for oil tanks, boilers, and hot water heaters. They aren’t technically a full-service heating provider, and they can’t work on all types of heating equipment. This limits the value of their service plans, but they still offer the core services that property owners need to keep their homes or businesses warm.
Additionally, John’s Fuel Oil, Inc now offers air conditioning repair and installation as of 2022. They aren’t the most experienced in this area, though, so customers looking for a heating and cooling provider may be better served by partnering with a company higher on the list.
- Value Score: 4.1
- Year Established: 1988
- Repair and Replacement Services?: Yes
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: Yes
- Other Home Services Offered: HVAC
- Contact: Johns Fuel Oil Inc. website
All Island Fuel
All Island Fuel is a heating oil and propane provider, making them somewhat limited, but we included them on this list because of their high volume of great reviews. Their claim to fame is competitive and transparent pricing, and they promise to beat any other company’s fuel oil price. This means they don’t offer the same full-service experience that companies higher on this list do that may provide more value, but that is simply so they can meet the needs of customers on a really tight budget. They do offer burner service and repair, though, which puts them one step up on heating oil-only firms in most cases.
- Value Score: 3.9
- Year Established: 1990
- Repair and Replacement Services?: Yes
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: No
- Other Home Services Offered: N/A
- Contact: All Island Fuel website
Meenan
Meenan is a full-service heating and cooling company that also offers some unique accessory services like chimney cleaning and generator installation. Their pricing and payment flexibility are impressive in many cases, but their Value Score was dinged significantly by some troubling review scores on a couple of the larger review sites. Concerns about the consistency of their quality and pricing kept them from being higher on the list, but they have been around a very long time and do have enough positive reviews to suggest that they offer good value overall.
- Value Score: 3.6
- Year Established: 1934
- Repair and Replacement Services?: Yes
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: Yes
- Other Home Services Offered: HVAC, Generators, Chimney service
- Contact: Meenan website
