Heating oil is the oldest home heating method still used in New York, and Brooklyn has countless options for heating oil delivery as a result. To help customers in the area figure out the best value for their home or business, we have researched over 35 of the best heating oil companies in Brooklyn, found out what home services and other valuable features they offer, and provided a ranking based on the following criteria:
- Value Score: A 1.0-5.0 score that incorporates the pricing of heating oil delivery and other services, their home service selection, quality (based on relevant reviews), and the expertise of their team.
- Year Established: We give older providers an edge since they’ve been able to stay in business by keeping Brooklyn residents and business owners happy.
- Replacement and Repair Services: Heating oil companies that can repair and install new heating equipment and oil tanks get priority since heating system faults are often discovered during delivery, and it’s much more convenient to have the company that discovers the issue handle the repair.
- 24/7 Emergency Service Availability: Heating system failures don’t always happen during the day, so we prefer companies that offer 24/7 emergency service.
- Other Home Services Offered: Getting good service from a company builds trust, and being able to get other home services from that same company gives customers more peace of mind since they already trust that provider’s work. As a result, we give a bump to companies with a wide service library.
Below are our rankings of the best heating oil companies in Brooklyn after considering all of the factors above:
The Best Heating Oil Companies in Brooklyn, NY
| Rank | Company | Value Score | Established | Replacement and Repair Services? | 24/7 Emergency Service? | Other Home Services Offered |
| 1 | Skaggs-Walsh | 4.8 | 1933 | Yes | Yes | HVAC, Plumbing, Electrical, Pest Control |
| 2 | Petro Home Service | 4.6 | 1903 | Yes | Yes | Oil and Gas Heat, HVAC, Generators |
| 3 | Ferrantino Fuel Company | 4.5 | 1935 | Yes | Yes | Plumbing,Natural Gas, Electrical |
| 4 | Rucci Oil | 4.3 | 1927 | Yes | Yes | HVAC, Plumbing |
| 5 | Atlantic & Pacific Oil Co. | 4.2 | 1934 | Yes | No | Plumbing, Natural Gas, Electrical |
| 6 | Cohler Fuel Oil Co, Inc. | 4.0 | 1939 | Yes | No | N/A |
| 7 | Paragon Oil | 3.9 | 1945 | Yes | No | N/A |
Skaggs-Walsh
Skaggs-Walsh is a family-owned heating oil company that has been in operation for almost a century and has since expanded into multiple home services. Their high-value score comes from their reasonable pricing, value-added service and tank protection plans, great reviews, and unique X-factors like their own 400,000 gallon fuel reserve that ensures they’ll never run out of fuel during the winter and their massive fleet of trucks that ensures they don’t get overbooked. They can repair heating systems, replace oil tanks, and remove your existing tank. They also offer consistent pricing, meaning you don’t have to rely on seasonal coupons or promo periods to lock in affordable heating oil delivery.
In addition to everything that makes them a top-notch heating oil company, they also offer the widest variety of home services on the list. These services aren’t afterthoughts, either– each of them is run through a local expert team that they acquired specifically for their positive reputation and the expertise of their leadership.
- Value Score: 4.8
- Year Established: 1933
- Repair and Replacement Services?: Yes
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: Yes
- Other Home Services Offered: HVAC, Plumbing, Electrical, Pest Control
- Contact: Skaggs-Walsh website
Petro Home Services
Petro Home Services is a fuel oil and home services company serving Brooklyn customers among a much larger service area across much of the Northwest. Their combination of fuel oil service and AC repair makes them a solid option for customers looking for year-round temperature control. They don’t offer the longest list of home services, but full-service HVAC with the added benefit of generator installation is still a respectable list.
They do offer flexible service plans, which makes them an even better value. They don’t rely on seasonal coupons or promotions to provide good value, so customers don’t have to worry about unexpected price increases.
- Value Score: 4.6
- Year Established: 1903
- Repair and Replacement Services?: Yes
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: Yes
- Other Home Services Offered: Oil and Gas Heat, HVAC, Generators
- Contact: Petro Home Service
Ferrantino Fuel Company
Ferrantino Fuel Company is one of the next-best-rated heating oil companies in Brooklyn. As with many firms on the list, they are over 80 years old, and have been serving the area for almost that entire tenure. They offer repair and replacement for heating oil tanks and heating systems, as well as plumbing, natural gas heating, and some electrical work. They do not handle AC systems, though, so they stop short of full HVAC services which dings them on our Value Score.
Their pricing is competitive, and they offer value-driven service plans with limited reliance on specials. Most discounts and specials are available year-round, so not all customers will get the best possible deal, but the ones who do qualify can at least rely on the price they have gotten used to.
- Value Score: 4.5
- Year Established: 1935
- Repair and Replacement Services?: Yes
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: Yes
- Other Home Services Offered: Plumbing, Natural Gas, Electrical
- Contact: Ferrantino Fuel Company website
Rucci Oil
Rucci Oil offers Brooklyn residents oil heating, HVAC, and plumbing services. They have been reviewed well for their pricing, offering a few different service plans to meet different budgetary needs. They don’t offer electrical services, but they can at least handle basically any climate control needs for homes and businesses. If you need some electrical work done to accommodate a new HVAC system, though, this means you’ll need to hire a separate company to get it done.
Overall, Rucci Oil isn’t as versatile as some other options on the list, but they offer enough to lock themselves in as a top three option for heating oil and other home services.
- Value Score: 4.3
- Year Established: 1927
- Repair and Replacement Services?: Yes
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: Yes
- Other Home Services Offered: HVAC, Plumbing
- Contact: Rucci Oil website
Atlantic & Pacific Oil Co.
Atlantic & Pacific Oil Company is another longstanding heating oil delivery and repair company, offering plumbing, electrical, and natural gas heating as well. While they are reviewed, well, they have a very small number of reviews, and we haven’t seen any for their non-heating oil services. So, while we can vouch for the quality of their oil delivery and heating system repair, we cannot confirm whether or not their plumbing and electrical services are up to snuff.
They also offer budget plans for oil delivery and service, which helps them earn a high-value score despite not having the widest variety of tried-and-true home services. However, they do not offer 24-hour emergency repair services, making them the only full-service heating company on the list that doesn’t.
- Value Score: 4.2
- Year Established: 1934
- Repair and Replacement Services?: Yes
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: No
- Other Home Services Offered: Plumbing, Natural Gas, Electrical
- Contact: Atlantic & Pacific Oil Co. website
Cohler Fuel Oil Co, Inc.
Cohler Fuel Oil Co, Inc., is a heating oil delivery company that offers no other home services, though they can repair and install replacement equipment. They provide value through both heating oil service plans and parts protection plans, and they don’t rely on or offer many promotional discounts on their website. This means their pricing is predictable, and reviews suggest it is affordable. While they don’t offer any other home services, they seem to do the best job possible for heating oil delivery alone.
- Value Score: 4.0
- Year Established: 1939
- Repair and Replacement Services?: Yes
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: No
- Other Home Services Offered: N/A
- Contact: Cohler Fuel Oil Co, Inc. website
Paragon Oil
Paragon Oil is another heating oil-only service provider. They do offer repair and replacement for heating oil tanks and heating systems, though, which earns them a spot on this list as a solid budget option for those not looking for any other home services. Their pricing is very competitive, but commensurate with their more limited service capabilities. They also do not offer 24-hour emergency repair, which may leave customers in some discomfort in the event that a system failure happens in the evening during the winter.
- Value Score: 3.9
- Year Established: 1945
- Repair and Replacement Services?: Yes
- 24/7 Emergency Service?: No
- Other Home Services Offered: N/A
- Contact: Paragon Oil website
