Heating oil is the home heat source for many of the historic properties in New York, and Westchester is no exception. To assist property owners in the area, we evaluated 30 of the top heating oil companies in Westchester, using data compiled from customer reviews, service records, pricing surveys, and industry benchmarks. We then found the best six options for homeowners and ranked them based on the following factors:
- Value Score: A 1.0-5.0 rating combining heating oil prices, service options, review quality, and team expertise
- 24/7 Emergency Service: Round-the-clock availability for heating emergencies gives firms an edge in our rankings
- Average Wait Time for Delivery: A shorter typical timeframe from order to oil delivery is a key factor in our ranking
- Replacement and Repair Services: We also give better rankings to companies that can repair and install heating oil equipment
- Year Established: Longer time in business demonstrates more experience in New York’s historic properties, consistent product quality, and reliable service
- Other Home Services: We give priority to firms that offer other home services as well, since that allows New York customers to get more of their home services from a firm that they trust
Below are our rankings of the best heating oil companies in Westchester after considering all of the factors above:
The Best Heating Oil Companies in Westchester
| Rank | Company | Value Score | Year Founded | Replacement/Repair Services? | 24/7 Emergency Service? | Avg Wait Time | Other Services |
| 1 | Skaggs-Walsh | 4.8 | 1933 | Yes | Yes | Same Day | Oil and Gas Heat, HVAC, Plumbing, Electrical, Pest Control |
| 2 | Petro Home Service | 4.6 | 1903 | Yes | Yes | 2-4 Days | Oil and Gas Heat, HVAC, Generators |
| 3 | Town & Country Oil | 4.3 | 1927 | Yes | Yes | 1-2 Days | Water Heaters |
| 4 | Pilgrim Oil Group | 3.6 | 2003 | Repair Only | No | 2-4 Days | Water Heaters |
| 5 | Superior Fuel Oil | 3.3 | 2009 | No | No | 2-5 Days | N/A |
| 6 | Slomins | 3.0 | 1920 | Yes | Yes | 3-6 Days | HVAC, Home Security Systems |
Skaggs-Walsh
Skaggs-Walsh earns the highest value score by combining competitive heating oil pricing, wide service breadth, excellent customer reviews, and well-known service reliability. Their 4.8 Value Score reflects superior performance across the entire criteria: fair pricing without hidden fees, immediate emergency response, and comprehensive technical expertise spanning heating, cooling, plumbing, and electrical services. Their heating oil delivery plans provide much more stable and affordable pricing than cash-on-delivery orders, though they do offer both.
The company’s greatest advantage lies in owning its own fuel terminal and truck fleet, ensuring consistent same-day oil availability even during regional shortages. Their technicians undergo extensive cross-training in multiple home systems, often resolving issues that would require multiple service calls from competitors. The 24/7 staffing model includes actual technicians on call, not just answering services, which means customers also get same-day emergency repairs.
Location: Manhattan, Queens, Bronx, Brooklyn, Westchester, Nassau, Western Suffolk
Value Score: 4.8
Year Established: 1933
Replacement/Repair Services: Yes
24/7 Emergency Service: Yes
Average Wait Time: Same Day
Other Services Offered: Oil and Gas Heat, HVAC, Plumbing, Electrical, Pest Control
Contact: Skaggs-Walsh website
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Customers consistently highlight “immediate response times,” “knowledgeable multi-skilled technicians,” and “honest pricing,” with many noting they can handle multiple home systems during a single visit. |
Petro Home Services
Petro receives a 4.6 Value Score due to extensive service offerings and mostly positive customer experiences. Their lock-in pricing programs are good for customers who want more predictable pricing, but some complaints about service wait times, quality, and complex contract terms impact their overall value proposition.
Recent customer feedback has revealed some issues with service quality and communication, with many reporting lengthy wait times for both deliveries and service calls. They make up for this a bit by offering several valuable home services and having a long track record of reliability.
Location: Multi-state coverage, including Westchester
Value Score: 4.6
Year Established: 1903
Replacement/Repair Services: Yes
24/7 Emergency Service: Yes
Average Wait Time: 2-4 Days
Other Services Offered: Oil and Gas Heat, HVAC, Generators
Contact: Petro Home Service website
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Mixed feedback shows “price protection benefits” and “wide service area” alongside frequent complaints about “high prices,” “long wait times,” and “difficult customer service.” Service quality varies significantly by location. |
Town & Country Oil
Town & Country Oil achieves strong value through specialized local knowledge and reliable service delivery within Westchester County. Their 4.3 Value Score reflects competitive pricing combined with above-average service quality and genuine customer relationship focus.
Their emergency response service consistently receives excellent ratings from local customers, though customers report that their 24/7 service availability is very limited.
The company’s Westchester-only focus allows technicians to become familiar with neighborhood-specific heating challenges and building types. Their repair and installation teams also have good reviews; their only major value drawback is that they offer no home services other than oil delivery, heating oil system repair/replacement, and water heater repair/installation.
Location: Westchester County
Value Score: 4.3
Year Established: 1927
Replacement/Repair Services: Yes
24/7 Emergency Service: Yes
Average Wait Time: 1-2 Days
Other Services Offered: Water Heaters
Contact: Town & Country Oil website
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Reviews emphasize “excellent customer service,” “fair and transparent pricing,” and “reliable emergency response” during business hours, as well as “professional installations.” Limited after-hours availability is mentioned as the only drawback. |
Pilgrim Oil Group
Pilgrim Oil Group is a fuel-buying group that earns a 3.6 value score by using collective purchasing power to secure discounted heating oil rates for Westchester County customers. They focus specifically on the local market through their “Oil For Less” group buying program, which can save customers up to $500 annually compared to regular cash-on-delivery providers.
The company’s business model centers on scheduled delivery days that maximize efficiency across neighborhoods. However, this coordination requires 2-4 days of advance planning for most deliveries, so there is no same-day delivery. Their limited repair services are only offered through partner contractors, so customers don’t really get to get both services from the same name that they trust.
Location: Multi-state coverage, including Westchester
Value Score: 3.6
Year Established: 2003
Replacement/Repair Services: Repair Only
24/7 Emergency Service: No
Average Wait Time: 2-4 Days
Other Services Offered: Water Heaters
Contact: Pilgrim Oil Group website
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Customers appreciate “significant cost savings through group buying,” “flexible payment options,” and “local Westchester focus” while noting “longer delivery windows” due to scheduled route coordination and “limited emergency availability.” |
Superior Fuel Oil
Superior Fuel Oil earns a 3.3 value score by focusing exclusively on the lowest-cost cash delivery without additional services. Their cash-only policy eliminates processing fees, giving them some of the region’s lowest per-gallon rates for customers who are comfortable with no additional service options or price-stabilizing service plans.
The model works for customers with predictable heating needs who plan deliveries well in advance. However, cash-only payments create inconvenience, their limited operating hours provide no emergency support when heating systems fail during off-hours, and the 2-5 day waiting period for deliveries can be tough to plan around if you do need fuel quickly.
Location: Westchester, Nassau, Suffolk Counties
Value Score: 3.3
Year Established: 2009
Replacement/Repair Services: No
24/7 Emergency Service: No
Average Wait Time: 2-5 Days
Other Services Offered: N/A
Contact: Superior Fuel Oil website
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Reviews highlight “lowest available prices” and “clean heating oil,” while noting “cash-only inconvenience,” “extended delivery windows,” and “no emergency or repair services” available. |
Slomins
Slomins receives the lowest value score at 3.0 due to significant customer satisfaction issues despite its long market presence. Their business model uses competitive oil pricing to attract customers to higher-margin security and HVAC services, creating more complex relationships that often frustrate customers seeking straightforward heating oil service.
Customer feedback reveals consistent problems with Slomins’ oil delivery service quality and contract terms, while their security installations and HVAC services receive better reviews. The bundling approach benefits customers who want integrated home services, but it can make things more difficult for those seeking simple oil delivery relationships. While they meet many of the X’s and O’s of our criteria, we had to bump them down the list for the pattern of negative reviews about their heating oil delivery service, specifically.
Location: Long Island, NYC area, Westchester
Value Score: 3.0
Year Established: 1920
Replacement/Repair Services: Yes
24/7 Emergency Service: Yes
Average Wait Time: 3-6 Days
Other Services Offered: HVAC, Home Security Systems
Contact: Superior Fuel Oil website
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Customer feedback highlights “competitive initial oil pricing” and “reliable security equipment,” but also frequent complaints about “poor oil delivery service,” “complex cancellation policies,” and “aggressive sales tactics” for security upgrades. |
